Science misconceptions
Correcting Science misconceptions through contrastive teaching
A practical way to examine a diagnosed misconception: ask students to explain their reasoning, discuss the evidence, explain the science, and check a different example.
A student can repeat a correct Science statement and still use a different idea when answering a question. Asking for an explanation and a reason can help you see which explanation they are using.
A contrastive lesson compares that explanation with suitable evidence and a clear scientific account. It is one teaching option, alongside explicit explanation, worked examples and guided practice. It does not guarantee that an idea will be replaced in one lesson.
The worked example below is for P6 photosynthesis, following the level placement in the MOE Primary Science syllabus. It is teacher guidance, not a pupil worksheet for every primary level. The discussion of fresh and dry mass is a teacher accuracy note, not an extra syllabus requirement.
Start with a specific learning need
"Plants get their food from soil" is a useful statement to investigate. Ask what the student means by food. They may be confusing food with water, mineral salts or fertiliser. Those are different starting points for teaching.
The same wrong answer can have different causes. Use the diagnostic questions guide to probe the reasoning before grouping students or choosing an activity.
A possible lesson sequence
The following sequence is a planning suggestion. Adjust it to your students and the available evidence; it is not a compulsory order established by research.
1. Ask for an explanation
Choose a situation that tests the diagnosed idea. Give students time to explain privately or in pairs before discussing responses. Avoid framing a wrong answer as a personal failure.
For a group confusing plant food with water, ask: "A pupil says: I watered my plant, so I have fed it. Do you agree? Explain what the plant makes as food and where the materials for making it come from." Discuss the reasoning, not just the yes-or-no answer.
2. Examine suitable evidence
Use a clear diagram, a worked example or an appropriately controlled investigation. Ask what the evidence shows and what it cannot show. Do not present invented classroom results as measured data.
For this example, use a labelled model showing water and carbon dioxide entering the plant, light supplying energy, and food and oxygen being produced. Ask students to identify which label represents food. Explain that a diagram represents the scientific model; it is not an observation made by the class.
An unexpected result does not explain itself. Check that students have interpreted the observation correctly before drawing a conclusion.
3. State the scientific explanation
For green plants, distinguish the roles clearly: plants use light energy to make food from water and carbon dioxide. Roots take in water and mineral salts; these are not the same as the food made by photosynthesis. Leaves are the main food-making organs in many familiar green plants.
Ask students to connect the explanation to their earlier response. Rosenshine's principles support explicit guidance, modelling and checks for understanding; they do not establish that contrast is always better than re-explanation.
4. Try a new context and revisit it
Ask students to explain a different situation without copying the first answer. For example: "A healthy green plant has water and air but is kept in darkness. Can it make food by photosynthesis during that time? Why?"
The expected distinction is that light is needed for photosynthesis. The question concerns food-making during that time, not a prediction of immediate death. Choose the depth of explanation to match what the class has been taught.
Use another brief check later. One correct response shows what the student could do on that occasion; it does not establish permanent understanding.
Take care with plant-mass examples
Avoid asking where all of a plant's extra mass came from unless the measurement and conditions are defined. A fresh plant contains much water, and changes in water content affect its measured mass. Dry mass is a different measurement.
The carbon in sugars made through photosynthesis comes from carbon dioxide. That does not mean every increase in fresh mass comes mostly from carbon dioxide, or that a change in soil mass alone proves the full source of plant growth. Water and mineral salts also have roles. For a primary lesson about making food, the simpler input-and-role explanation above avoids an unnecessary mass-accounting problem.
Before using the lesson
Check that the prompt identifies the idea you want to teach, the evidence supports your conclusion, and the explanation does not introduce another misconception. Prepare a follow-up question that changes the context without adding an untaught concept.
The remedial lesson-planning guide can help organise the sequence. MyScienceHOD's beta information explains current access and teacher tools. Follow your school's data-handling policy and use only the supported workflows available to your account. Real pupil-script intake remains closed; do not upload real pupil scripts.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
- Does contrasting ideas guarantee that a misconception disappears?
- No. A contrast may help a student examine an idea, but the student may need further explanation and practice. Check their reasoning in another context and revisit it later.
- Should every correction start with a surprising demonstration?
- No. Choose an explanation, worked example or carefully controlled comparison that addresses the diagnosed need. A surprising result can confuse students if the observation or explanation is unclear.
Sources and further reading
- OfficialMOE Primary Science Syllabus 2023: Photosynthesis, printed pages 78-79 (P6)
- ResearchRosenshine, B. (2012). Principles of Instruction, American Educator (Spring 2012)
- ResearchOregon State University Extension: Environmental factors affecting plant growth
Last reviewed for accuracy: 2026-11-12